Jan 18 2007 INDIA: An Estimated amount of over 300 crore rupees is spent by the INDIAN Government as Haj subsidy for Muslims per year. The Subsidy Includes a Subsidized Air Ticket to Saudi Arabia, Free Food, Free Accommodation and so on. On the Other Hand all other religion in INDIA are deprived of any such Offers from the Government.
Recently a business man named Prafull Goradia who is also a BJP MP filed a PIL before the Supreme Court alleging this practice as Unconstitutional and a severe drain on the tax payer's money.
- Such a Grand is only given to Muslims and no other religion in INDIA gets any such favors,which is a direct violation of Articles 14, 15 and 17 of the Constitution which provide equal status to all Indians irrespective of their religion or cast.
- Also the money given as subsidy is took from tax paid by all INDIAN citizen which include not only Muslims but Hindus, Christians, Sikhs and so on and the Article 27 of Constitution of INDIA states that, "no person shall be compelled to pay any taxes, the proceeds of which are specifically appropriated for the payment of expenses for the promotion and maintenance of any particular religion."
While the Critics may say Government is doing special arrangements like arranging special trains and buses for occasions like Kumbh Mela, it should also be acknowledged that the Government does this for all festival occasions irrespective of religion or cast every where in INDIA. Besides every devote who goes to Kumbh Mela has to pay the full ticket and the tickets are not subsidized
The Supreme Court has asked the Governments explanation on this matter..
And I will be looking forward to see what the verdict would be...
My Views:
Haj subsidy as mentioned above is unconstitutional and hence must be abolished
Terms Used:
Crore: A sum of ten Million Rupees
Haj: A Religious visit undertook by Muslims to mecca
PIL: Public Interest Litigation, means litigation filed on court to protect public interest
Kumbh Mela: A hindu pilgrimage that occurs four times every twelve year





